Snazzy and innately passionate Karolyn experiences a sudden and disruptive breakup on the same day she meets her enigmatic handsome new barber, Louis.

On the rebound, Karolyn finds herself going back to his barbershop for more than just the full-service haircuts, even after she realizes he is married. At first, it is only playful flirting on both their parts, but gradually she becomes obsessed with winning his affection.

Betraying her beliefs, Karolyn goes against her own rules and falls for Louis, starting an erotic, raunchy affair with him. As quickly as it begins, Louis runs back to his family, deserting her on an island inn. Shattered, she is left on the verge of an emotional breakdown.

However, Mercy steps in to pick up the pieces as Karolyn is brought together with John, a single, soft-spoken, well-meaning Christian. He is perfectly capable of giving her the 'happily ever after' she always desired, except she is unsure of her feelings for him.

As her heart heals, she is about to realize her true feelings for John, when Louis again crosses her path. Now she must choose whether to mind once more the things of her throbbing flesh, or pursue an uncertain relationship hoping to find lifelong love.