After he cruelly humiliated her at her eighth-grade dance, Annabelle Richards wants nothing to do with Jordan Myers. Even when a chance encounter sends Jordan crashing back into her life ten years later, Annabelle is sure of this. But living in such a small town makes hiding difficult, and Annabelle soon finds that she is seeing more and more of Jordan, who appears to be eager to put the past behind them. He once made her life miserable, turning her into an outcast, yet now, rather than the feelings of resentment and anger he once inspired, Annabelle finds that he gives her... butterflies?

Despite Annabelle's best efforts, the two become closer and closer, and she begins to re-evaluate everything she ever thought about him. Can people truly change? Or will it turn out that she was right about him all along?